Colleges and universities are pouring more budget and bandwidth into recruitment and not seeing the return. Funnels are stalling. Costs are climbing. Yield is unpredictable. And students are checking out without warning. It’s not a lack of effort. It’s a system that isn’t built for how students decide now. Put simply, the model is broken.
Institutions are operating in a fundamentally different environment than the one this recruitment playbook was built for. Attention is fragmented. Expectations are higher. And personalization that stops at a first name is no longer enough. Continuing to rely on outdated recruitment models doesn’t just slow progress, it puts institutions at a competitive disadvantage.
The legacy model doesn’t match how students decide today
Many recruitment strategies still rely on a familiar set of assumptions:
- Students move predictably through a linear funnel
- Stage-based triggers signal readiness to advance
- Communication plans can be prebuilt and scaled
- Historical reports provide enough insight to guide what comes next
This model was designed for a time when student journeys were more linear and decision-making was easier to anticipate. But that’s not the reality institutions are recruiting into today.
Today’s learners don’t follow a neat path from awareness to enrollment. They research across devices. They pause and re-engage on their own timelines. They evaluate cost, outcomes, flexibility, reputation, and support — often all at once. And they expect institutions to recognize their needs without forcing them to repeat themselves at every step.
When recruitment strategies rely on stage-based signals alone, they miss what actually matters: behavior.
Two students may both be labeled “inquiry stage,” but one may be ready to apply while the other is still building trust. Treating them the same doesn’t create efficiency. It creates friction.
This is where the traditional recruitment playbook breaks down. Funnels show movement, but they don’t explain motivation. They don’t reveal intent. And they don’t equip institutions to respond in the moments that matter most.
Higher education leaders are increasingly naming this gap as an inflection point. As Arizona State University President Michael Crow has argued, institutions face an “evolve or die” moment, one that underscores the risk of continuing to rely on models built for a different era. His framing isn’t about alarmism. It’s about recognizing when long-standing approaches no longer align with how learners actually discover, evaluate, and choose where to enroll.
Recruitment sits squarely inside that challenge. When institutions continue to optimize outdated models rather than rethink them, they reinforce systems that no longer reflect how students decide today.
Shifting from funnel management to student experience
Forward-looking institutions are changing the question. Instead of asking, “Where is this student in the funnel?” they’re asking, “What does this student need right now?”
That shift requires more than new messaging or additional channels. It requires a different recruitment model — one built around experience, not sequence.
It calls for a model that brings marketing, enrollment, and engagement together into a single, coordinated system that uses data not just to report outcomes, but to guide decisions in real time and respond to students as individuals rather than averages.
Turning student data into actionable intelligence
What leading institutions are moving toward isn’t a new tool or platform. It’s a more sophisticated way of understanding students, and it starts with data.
Think of it as creating a “digital twin” of each student — a living, continuously evolving model that reflects how an individual actually engages across channels, systems, and moments in time. Rather than relying on static personas or stage-based assumptions, this approach combines behavioral signals, engagement data, and institutional context to surface real insights into student intent.
What does that enable?
- Website behavior that signals readiness or hesitation
- Device usage that informs how (and where) to engage
- Content engagement that reveals what matters most to the student
- Patterns over time that help predict next best actions
With this level of intelligence, institutions don’t have to wait for students to raise their hands or move to the next stage. They can anticipate needs and respond with relevance. Outreach becomes more timely, conversations feel more personal, and trust builds earlier in the journey.
This isn’t about automation or scale for its own sake. It’s about using data intentionally—to create recruitment experiences that reflect how students actually make decisions.
Why most providers can’t deliver this
Many service providers talk about personalization, but few can operationalize it.
Traditional models are constrained by their structure: email-heavy communication, predefined workflows, and limited visibility into what’s actually happening across the recruitment journey. Even when data is collected, it’s often siloed, static, or disconnected from human engagement.
A model built on real-time student intelligence requires something fundamentally different:
- Unified data environments grounded in actual behavior
- Transparent access to insights within institutional systems
- Multichannel engagement guided by data, not dictated by it
- Human expertise embedded alongside technology
It also requires the ability to scale personalization without sacrificing experience, supporting thousands of students while still treating each one as an individual.
What a modern recruitment partner looks like
As recruitment models evolve, expectations of partnership must evolve with them.
Institutions need partners who do more than generate demand. They need partners who help convert it. Partners who embed alongside internal teams bring a strategic perspective and adapt as student behavior shifts. Partners who can support across learner types and enrollment moments, not just the most profitable ones.
Most importantly, institutions need partners with a proven approach — one grounded in data, enabled by technology, and delivered by people who understand the complexity of enrollment today.
It’s time for a new recruitment playbook
The institutions that succeed next won’t recruit harder. They’ll recruit smarter.
They’ll move beyond linear funnels and static campaigns. They’ll replace assumptions with insight. And they’ll design recruitment experiences that reflect how students actually make decisions — not how we wish they did.
The rules of recruitment have already changed. The only question is whether institutions will continue running the old plays or adjust to a game plan built for what comes next.
Innovation Starts Here
Higher ed is evolving — don’t get left behind. Explore how Collegis can help your institution thrive.